RIFTSPINNER

FIELD NOTES

Designing melee in a game built around guns

Three rigs that cannot shoot, why they were underpowered, and the numbers we changed to fix them.

By CablingGod Ltd, the studio behind Riftspinner · Published · 6 minute read

PLAY FREE IN YOUR BROWSER

Riftspinner began as a game about shooting. The core loop, the enemy roster, the level-up cards and the loot tables were all built around bullets crossing a screen. The three melee rigs came later, and they carried a built-in problem: in a game where most dangers can be handled from a distance, asking a player to stand at arm's length from them has to be paid for somewhere. This article explains how the Bulwark, Harrow and Gyre work, what we found wrong with them, and the changes made in build 20261050 to bring them into line.

Three implements, three jobs

Each melee rig carries a different implement. Their base figures, from the game's data, before any rarity or upgrades:

ImplementRigDamageSwings/sDPS per targetReach (px)ArcKnockbackStun
Slam MaulBulwark401.144.0120120 degrees4200.35 s
Reaper ScytheHarrow202.346.0128195 degrees130-
Gyre BladesGyre123.542.072full circle90-

The Slam Maul is the heavy hitter. It deals 40 damage about once a second across a wide front arc, with the heaviest knockback in the game (420) and a 0.35 second stun on everything it touches. It is a crowd-control tool as much as a damage tool: a slam both removes enemies from your face and holds them still while they are there. The Reaper Scythe trades weight for rhythm. It deals 20 per sweep, more than twice a second, through an arc of nearly 200 degrees, and it knocks hostile shots out of the air. The Gyre Blades are the odd one out: four blades orbit you continuously, each hitting for 12 up to 3.5 times a second in a full circle around you, and holding fire widens and speeds the orbit.

Single-target damage per second works out at 44.0 for the Maul, 46.0 for the Scythe and 42.0 per blade for the Gyre. Set that against the Issue Carbine's 54.6 and the design intent is visible: a melee implement does roughly 80% of a starting gun to one target. The balance has to come from somewhere else, because a player who has accepted the risk of getting close needs a reason to have done so. That reason is that melee hits everything in its arc at once, and in a game that throws crowds at you, that is worth far more than the 20% it costs.

What was wrong

When we sat down to improve the melee rigs, three problems stood out, and none of them was about the weapons' base numbers.

The rigs paid the risk and did not get the reward. The Bulwark was a tank without enough tank: its extra health was modest and its speed penalty was a full 10%, so it was slow and still dying. The Harrow carried a health penalty, which on a rig that must stand in melee range is the wrong direction. The Gyre's blades were strong in theory but spinning slowed you by 20%, so using the signature move made you easier to hit.

A trait that did nothing. The loot system rolls bonus traits onto weapons. One of them, pierce, is a gun trait that makes a bullet pass through targets. Melee weapons could roll it, and on a blade it did absolutely nothing. A player who found a melee implement with that trait had been handed a dead affix.

Rarity scaled the wrong stats too gently. For a blade, the numbers that matter are swing speed and reach, and moving up a rarity tier raised them by only 28% and 7% respectively.

The changes

The Bulwark now has +90 health (it had +60), 16% damage soak (12% before) and a speed penalty of only 6% (10% before). Its slams also gained Aftershock: everything around you in a full ring takes 40% of the slam. That sounds like a numbers tweak, but it changes the rig's shape. The Maul's front arc is wide but not total, and a tank surrounded by enemies on every side used to be rewarded only for the ones it faced. Aftershock makes standing in the middle of a crowd the point of the rig.

The Harrow lost its health penalty and gained a better kit: 8% lifesteal (was 6%), 12% speed (was 8%) and 10% crit chance. It also got Frenzy Cut. A sweep that hits three or more hosts refunds 35% of its recharge. This rewards exactly the behaviour the Scythe's wide arc invites, which is to stay in contact with a cluster and keep swinging, and it means a good sweep feeds the next one.

The Gyre now orbits four blades from the start, with the Cyclone Blades evolution adding a fifth. Spinning slows you by only 10% (was 20%), hits 50% harder while spinning (was 35%) and the rig gained 30 pickup reach and 6% soak. The point of the change is that using the signature move should not be a trade against survival.

Underneath, the weapons gained a little: Slam Maul base damage 34 to 40, Reaper Scythe 17 to 20, Gyre Blades 10 to 12, with reach up by a few pixels and swing rates slightly higher. Rarity now scales melee fire rate by 34% per tier instead of 28%, and reach by 10% instead of 7%. And the dead trait was fixed rather than removed: on a melee weapon, pierce now gives 12% more reach and 15% more knockback.

The abilities followed. Bulwark's Quake, a shockwave dealing four times damage with a 1.6 second stun and three seconds of Ward, now recharges in 24 seconds (28 before). Harrow's Cyclone, three seconds of whirling blades that feed you, recharges in 22 (24 before).

A lesson from the boss fight

The most instructive mistake was not in the melee rigs at all. Our bosses limit how much health a single hit can remove, so that one lucky shot cannot delete them. That cap was tuned for guns, expressed as a fraction of the boss's health per hit. When a melee weapon, which hits far less often than a gun but harder, was held to the same fraction, it became nearly useless against bosses, because its one big hit was clipped to the same ceiling as a bullet's. The fix was to give melee its own limit. The new end boss takes at most 0.8% of its health from one gun hit and 1.4% from one melee hit, which keeps both from trivialising the fight and keeps the heavier swings worth making. The general rule we took from it: every new damage type needs its own balance pass, because rules tuned for one will quietly break another.

What melee rigs cannot do

Melee rigs are not simply guns with the range removed. They have no weapon training in the Ash Market, because every one of those twelve upgrades is for a gun type. Many level-up mutations are gun-specific and never appear for them. Static Bite and the Static Coil trinket do work on melee, and the evolutions for the three implements (Fault Maul, Harvest Scythe and Cyclone Blades) are their own branch. The practical result is that a melee build leans on the core Ash Market upgrades, on armour and soak, on rarity and on its ability, where a gun build has more places to put its ash.

Playing them

A few tips follow from the design. Bulwark: do not kite. The rig is built to stand in a crowd, with Aftershock, soak and health to survive it, and its ability is a panic button that also buys time. Harrow: prefer clusters to singles, because Frenzy Cut only triggers on three or more hits, and the Scythe's shot deflection means it can sweep through ranged enemies' fire. Gyre: keep moving, since its blades protect you on every side but the slow while spinning is the cost, and hold fire to widen the ring when a crowd closes in.

We should be clear about what we have not done. These changes were tested with automated runs, including forced-spawn stress runs on two melee rigs. They have not been balanced against a large number of real players, so treat the numbers here as a first pass. If a melee rig feels wrong to you, in either direction, tell us what you were doing and which wave you were on; that is exactly the evidence that numbers in a table cannot give us.